Showing posts with label History. Show all posts
Showing posts with label History. Show all posts

Sunday, October 11, 2026

The Demon of Unrest by Erik Larson

I'll read anything Erik Larson writes. He has a brilliant way of weaving his inexhaustible research into a compelling story. So when I saw he had a new book out, The Demon of Unrest, it went immediately onto my reading list. 

I'm a big fan of the history of the Civil War (and actually all of American history), so I was fascinated by how Larson could take a well-known tidbit of the Civil War -- the firing on Fort Sumter -- and turn it into a full-fledged story. Of course he accomplished this; he's Erik Larson.

He weaves a tale by focusing on a few key players. He begins with Major Robert Anderson, Sumter’s commander and a former slave owner sympathetic to the South but loyal to the Union, contrasting him with Edmund Ruffin, a vain and bloodthirsty radical who stirs secessionist ardor at every opportunity. He includes the delightful and catty Mary Boykin Chesnut, whose diary provides a fascinating peek into antebellum high culture. Woven throughout is newly elected President Abraham Lincoln, battling with the forces of time and awful communication. In addition, his frenemy and Secretary of State, William Seward, complicates matters at every turn. 

While we know that Fort Sumter will be fired upon by South Carolina, Larson has a fascinating way of making the inevitable less so. By giving us a window into the challenges Major Anderson faced, we can see how the march of time and the lack of clear communication pushed the nation inexorably towards Civil War. The timing was the worst it could be. Lincoln had been elected and that threw South Carolina into what it saw as a desperate fight for survival. But, Lincoln would not become president for another four months. That left the weak and indecisive Buchanan at the helm during these most critical days. The South thought Buchanan sympathetic to their cause and so believed succession would be a simple matter, like an amicable divorce. Just clean up a few house-keeping details and move on to separate lives. Buchanan did not actually see it that way, but decided to kick the can down the road to his successor. 

Meanwhile, Lincoln was chomping at the bit to exercise power he did not yet have. He saw clearly that the South must not be allow to leave the Union. At a minimum, federal properties must be protected and reinforced. In frustration, he watched Buchanan dicker and let the all-important forts in the South Carolina harbor be taken over and reinforced by the Confederacy.

This uncertainty and lack of clear direction forced Major Anderson's hand. Finding the still-under-construction Fort Sumter to be the most defensible property, he evacuated all the federal forces to it. While the surrounding military installations constructed batteries aimed exclusively at Sumter, Anderson was running low on provisions and materiel. Although the South was allowed by Buchanan to pour men and resources into their stolen forts, any act of reinforcement by Anderson was seen as an act of war. 

Lincoln faced an increasingly untenable situation. Sumter needed reinforcements, but that very act would drive more states into the Confederacy and very likely start a war. Realizing that he had no choice -- Sumter must be either surrendered or reinforced -- Lincoln approved a misguided and poorly planned mission to provide food and sneak in soldiers to the embattled location. The weather, hubris of the officers in charge, Southern batteries, and miscommunication conspired to assure the planned resupply never happened. 

Sumter fought valiantly, but once it became ablaze, all hope was lost. 

Adding insult to injury, Anderson demanded a 100-gun salute to the bravery of the defenders. Miraculously, not one person at Sumter had died in the battle. And yet, one of the cannons exploded during the salute killing one soldier. After the man was properly buried at sea, Anderson ordered the salute to continue, but limited it to 50. What a perfect picture of all that had gone wrong. So many, thinking they were doing the "honorable" thing, led to such eventual bloodshed. 

Larson does a great job of telling "the rest of the story." He contrasts the "chivalry" (upper echelons of Southern society) and their elation at the start of the war to their eventual downfall. The Chesnuts lose everything; Ruffin shoots himself when he sees that his dream had turned into a nightmare. And the reader knows the horrifying destruction wrought by Americans killing other Americans. 

Larson ends with a chilling anecdote: Anderson is invited back to Sumter for a celebration at the war's end. The fort itself is in terrible shape, having been battered by Union forces over the course of the war. Anderson is a shell of his former self, never having recovered from the stress he faced in those months of uncertainty. At a dinner celebrating the victory, Anderson offers a toast to Lincoln and contrasts Lincoln ascension to the White House, under threat to assassination, to Lincoln's apparent security in a reunified nation. He had no idea that Lincoln lay dying at that very moment. 

So much tragedy. So much possibility of a different outcome, and yet so much seems inevitable: all the elements of a great story. 

Saturday, July 25, 2026

Murder in the Cathedral by T.S. Eliot

Murder in the Cathedral by T.S. Eliot is on my list of books to read "before I die." Plus I really like what little I've read of Eliot (Prufrock, Wasteland). 

But... I did not love this book. 

I thought I would. I'm familiar with the story he is dramatizing and I love it.

But it was just too... esoteric.

It's a play, which I didn't know. It has a chorus, which is odd. It's written in verse, which is tough. It assumes a lot!

So I read it. I can check it off. I'm not recommending it.

Friday, July 24, 2026

Copperhead by Bernard Cornwell

 This book, Copperhead by Bernard Cornwell, is the second in the Nathaniel Starbuck Chronicles, telling the story of the son of an abolitionist preacher who decides to fight for the South in the Civil War.

Starbuck is forced out of his beloved Falconer unit by the head of the unit itself, Washington Falconer. After murdering Falconer's future son-in-law for his treatment of Starbuck's love interest, Falconer banishes him.

Neither fish nor fowl, Starbuck has nowhere to go. Meanwhile his best friend, Falconer's son Adam, has decided to spy for the Union. Starbuck, himself, is caught and interrogated as the spy. After realizing that both Adam and Starbuck's brother James are implicated, he must walk a tight line to secure his freedom and the good graces of the South while avoiding betraying those he cares about. 

While seeming to "defect" to the North, he plays the role of double-agent for the ruthless Lieutenant de'Ath. But just as Starbuck returns to the South to betray the North, he learns of de'Ath's death. Who will protect him now?

He blackmails Adam saying he will reveal his duplicity to his father if Adam cannot secure a spot for Starbuck back with the Falconer Legion. Adam concedes, but appears to lose his mind in the end. 

We end our story with Starbuck back where he belongs. 

Friday, July 3, 2026

Rebel by Bernard Cornwell

One of my favorite historical fiction authors is Bernard Cornwell, so I decided to jump into his Nathaniel Starbuck Chronicles with Rebel, which takes place during the Civil War.

It's an easy read about an unlikely confederate: Nathaniel Starbuck is the son of a Northern abolitionist preacher. Although he was destined for the ministry himself, Starbuck makes a series of bad choices that land him desperate and destitute in Virginia just as Fort Sumter is fired upon. 

He must choose a side. 

And as so often happens, that choice depends on a girl. 

Once he has chosen to abandon his family and his family's values, he leads a ragtag, amateur bunch of hopped up Virginians in the Battle of Bull Run... where they flee in defeat. But that battle is just beginning and Starbuck will live to see the Southeventually defeat the North soundly in that first major battle. 

Now I have to read the next one!

At first, I was a bit disappointed that Starbuck saw his religious family and its values as worthy of rejection. Obviously, I heartily disagree. I also don't love that he's fighting for slavery and the right to own people. 

But it's Cornwell. I think he relishes making religion, specifically Christianity, look hypocritical and soul-crushing. It's more fun to rebel against the True, Good, and Beautiful. I should have expected nothing less. In Cornwell's world up is down and good is bad and morality is how you define it. I guess that works in fiction, but I know enough to know it's a fools errand. 

But it is awfully fun to read and to relive history that way!

 

Tuesday, June 30, 2026

George Washington's Secret Six by Brian Kilmeade and Don Yaeger

A good friend saw this book at a thrift store and thought of me: George Washington's Secret Six by Brian Kilmeade and Don Yaeger. I'm glad she did. 

I was familiar with story, especially after watching the show Turn, but reading about it was fun.

It tells the harrowing story of six people, centered around Abraham Woodhull (aka Samuel Culper), who smuggle information about New York city to Washington. It's obviously a dangerous job as Nathan Hale had already been hung after being caught as a spy. 

The ring involves Woodhull, a neighbor and tavern owner Austin Roe, printer and coffee shop owner, James Rivington, river boat pilot, Caleb Brewster, shopkeeper Robert Townsend, and the mysterious female agent, 355. All would collect information and add whatever they could as the correspondence made its way to Washington. 

They specifically noticed troop movements and the location and type of military equipment located in and around Manhattan. They were instrumental in diverting attention when the French entered the war on the American side, as well as alerting Washington to the British plans in regards to the French. 

Unfortunately, by its very nature, the spies were accorded little affirmation after the war was won. Some, like James Rivington suffered harm. Being thought of as a staunch loyalist, his cultivated persona, his newspaper suffered and he ended up in debtors prison. Others simply disappeared into the sands of time until discovered years later. We still don't know, and probably never will, who Agent 355 is. She probably died in, or at least was captured and sent to, a hellish prison ship. 

We certainly owe these patriots a debt of honor.

Monday, June 22, 2026

The American Spirit by David McCullough

I bought The American Spirit by David McCullough while visiting a charming bookstore in the historic town of Hillsborough. McCullough is one of my favorite historians and this small paperback seemed approachable. I didn't realize it's simply a collection of speeches he has given over the years. Once I read the first one, I lost interest. It seemed too different from my expectations. But finally, I picked it up and read the rest. In one day. It's that good and that easy to lose yourself in. 

Each speech is a delightful slice of American History, tailored to the local audience. We meet interesting Americans and recall events organized around whatever theme upon which McCullough has chosen to focus. Each is only a few pages long, so it is easy to think, "Just one more." (Which I did until I finished them all!)

My favorite was a speech delivered at Hillsdale College in 2005 (probably not a coincidence, but in fairness, it was really good!), titled, "Knowing Who We Are." He uses the example of the Adams family, John, Abigail, and John Quincy to remind all of us the beautiful inheritance we've been gifted. I love Abigail's admonition to her son upon hearing that he has become a little too big for his britches after being given every advantage: 

"If you are conscious to yourself that you possess more knowledge upon some subjects than others of your standing, reflect that you have had greater opportunities of seeing the world and obtaining knowledge of mankind than any of your contemporaries. That you have never wanted a book, but it has been supplied to you. That your whole time has been spent in the company of men of literature and science. How unpardonable would it have been in you to have turned out a blockhead (p. 118). 

If I ever give a commencement speech of my own, I want to use this! I love this woman!

Despite my initial reticence, McCullough does not disappoint!

Tuesday, June 16, 2026

The Great Contradiction by Joseph J. Ellis

I seem to be on a Joseph Ellis kick. He's quickly becoming a favorite American historian. The Great Contradiction by Joseph J. Ellis dives into the two great missed opportunities at our country's founding: slavery and the treatment of Native Americans. 

He begins with the great conundrum faced by the Founders. Slavery was already entrenched and yet they had declared "All men are created equal." For the time being, it was enough to assume that meant each colonist was equal to the King. But in the back of their minds, they knew this could equally be applied to the slave. The immovable wall they faced was the how. The North began emancipation immediately in one form or another, but the South saw slavery as too entrenched. Fearing a decimated economy, and naturally suspicious of the other states, the South stood absolutely opposed to any movement away from slavery as a legal and recognized institution. 

Benjamin Franklin's Pennsylvania Abolition Society brought the issue to the first Congress to debate. Clearly the Founding generation knew this was a contradiction and many felt the sooner it was dealt with, the better. But the better angels making the case for freedom were silenced by a recalcitrant South. Not only was emancipation off the table, the first Congress decided to table the issue... indefinitely. They saw it as too inherently destabilizing. We need to remember how fragile The United States actually was. In truth, the colonies only united to defeat the British. That accomplished, they reverted to thirteen independent states, with little to no regard for a central national government. Like their European forebears, they squabbled and threatened each other. It was easy to envision one or more enlisting the help of European allies to declare war on another state. A complete lack of a functioning national government meant the union was helpless to defend itself. A nation not united would easily fall victim to any enterprising power with the patience to wait (see: War of 1812). Demonstrating the most human of all characteristics, they put the matter off for another day, hoping that the future would provide a way out they could not fathom. 

Recalling various missed opportunities, Ellis describes what he terms, "Unpainted Pictures." He begins with the number of African Americans who served in the fight for Independence. This provides a never-realized glimpse of what America could have become, a bi-racial nation embracing equality of all. The geography of the battle, however, worked against this vision. Most of the battle occurred in the North where few slaves lived, and therefore their service and possible emancipation were less threatening. The British had offered freedom to any slaves in the South that joined their ranks. Thousands fled. (Sadly, most of these died of diseases from which they had no immunity.) This meant the South spent their time fighting fleeing slaves rather than welcoming them into the fight against the British. Ellis seems to feel this was the biggest missed opportunity of them all. "The Cause," that is the fight for freedom and equality, was permeating the colonies. During the war, with all its exigencies, they had a chance to rectify a situation handed them by History. But despite the favorable winds, they simply could not overcome the status quo. Although fighting under the banner of The United States, each state felt the fight was for their own individual independence. Therefore any kind of national policy concerning slavery was impossible to pursue, despite the obvious benefits to The Cause.

The second area of contradiction was the treatment of the Native Americans. The Treaty of Paris, signed after the British defeat, gave large swathes of land to the newly formed United States. This effectively handed them areas previously claimed by the natives. America largely chose to treat the Indians, therefore, as a "conquered" people, although they had not, in fact, been conquered, and had not signed the treaty between the U.S. and Britain. While the newly formed American government debated how best to approach obvious conflicts over land, the new Americans took matters into their own hands. They poured into the newly won Western lands faster than the national government could create and enforce policies. One treaty that could have given the Native Americans most of Georgia, Mississippi, and Alabama was undermined by Georgia's state government. Not wanting to lose half of their territory, they encouraged white settlers to flood over the borders. Although the government of the United States had promised to enforce that border, the idea of going to war with its own citizen proved too preposterous to even contemplate. Besides, America had no army capable of protecting a border of the size promised anyways. Indian policy quickly became a loosing battle when faced with the insatiable desire for land from the white settlers.  

Ellis closes with a touching "Unpainted Picture" from Mount Vernon and Monticello. Both Washington and Jefferson saw the contradictions they inherited. Washington chose to free his slaves upon his death, and Martha, fearing an insurrection from her family slaves freed hers as well at that time. Interestingly, Washington divided Mount Vernon among his five inheritors, thus seeming to ensure the negation of Mount Vernon as place locked in time, forever identifying Washington as a slave-owning southern planter. He appears to have wanted a legacy centered around his contributions to the American project to define him. Shortly before the Civil War, however, a group of southern women bought up the property and restored the legacy Washington, himself, seemed to want to bury. 

Jefferson, deeply in debt, had no such luxury available to him. In fact, he did not actually own his slaves, his creditors did. They were sold along with all his possessions when he died. While he saw the contradiction between his immortal words and his life, his inability to resolve that contradiction seems, unlike Washington, to have entrenched his Southern Plantation Owner identity. Even Monticello became a picture of that contradiction: dark-skinned slaves were hidden from the view of visitors; light-skinned slaves, many related to the Jefferson family, populated the mansion. Jefferson became convinced that a bi- or multi-racial society was impossible (despite the fact that he lived it day after day in his own home). Back of the napkin calculations for removing the African Americans to Africa or even much farther West revealed the hopelessness of that remedy. If the most enlightened mind of the early 19th century could not discover a way out of the contradiction, many believed it must, therefore, be a truly impossible situation. 

Ellis does a beautiful job telling the story of the great contradictions at the heart of the American Experiment from the inside. We are left time and again wishing History could have proceeded in a different manner, yet time and again coming up against the hard wall of reality. While a few missed opportunities existed, the obstacles to living up to our ideals so early in The Experiment prove insurmountable. If the most educated and enlightened minds, those most familiar with the contingencies of their times, could not see a way through, we fool ourselves if we believe we could have done better. Ellis is both condemnatory and sympathetic. We, two and half centuries later, as least have the consolation of knowing that The Cause continued to inspire Americans to fight for the realization of our Founding principles. We continue to fight for them today. 

Thursday, June 4, 2026

The Remembered Soldier by Anjet Daanje

Our book club always chooses from among several possible reads. I decided to also read the ones that didn't make the cut if possible. One that didn't was The Remembered Soldier by Anjet Daanje. Oh my goodness. I don't remember what we read instead, but I am so glad a read this book as well.

The book is about a man, named Noon at the beginning, who fought in World War I, but has lost his memory. He has spent the four years following the war in an asylum while waiting to be found by his family. Every woman he meets, desperate to believe he is her long-lost husband, fills him with so much angst at their disappointment, that he demands to be left alone. But one woman would not be denied, Julienne Coppens. She demands he see her and to his shock she declares him her long-long Amand, even identifying a mole under the hair on his head. 

With great trepidation, he goes home to Belgium with her. The novel continues telling the story of the following year in which they become reacquainted. As can be assumed, lots of hesitation and misunderstandings ensue as well as a blossoming of genuine love. Although both of their entire families and their home were lost in the war, Julie has started a new life in a new town and together they work to build the fledgling photography business she runs. Yet Amand never remembers a single moment. And Julie is clearly lying about some of the details. Their trust is on shaky ground.

Over time, Amand starts to experience moments as a different man. He feels like he is slipping into a psychotic break down. The lost time is happening more frequently, for longer periods, and he is often volatile and dangerous in these states. In addition, he is suffering from extreme "shell shock" and frequently dreams of the horrors he witnessed. A yellow woman with long, blond hair haunts those dreams. Is she death itself? Eventually Julienne and Amand make a plan for when the "other man" fully consumes him and he becomes, once again, a total stranger. They will reestablish their relationship with a collection of photos and letters and force him to live as her husband, Amand.

As expected, one day Amand becomes "Louis" and seems incapable of returning to his old self. He insists he is married to Kathe, a German woman with long, blond hair. He can't remember exactly where he is from, but he becomes increasingly angry with the strange woman, Julie, who claims to be his wife. Even the letters and photographs which were supposed to prove he was her husband Amand make him angry and suspicious. After a few weeks of increasing turmoil, Julie buys Amand a train ticket to a town in Germany that he senses is his home. Off he goes with a suitcase, some food, a few francs, and a destination. He arrives in a war-torn, highly impoverished nation where his money is no good, his suitcase is stolen, and the trains no longer run. 

I don't want to give away the ending, but suffice it to say that it is very satisfying. 

One issue with the book is that it is long. And yet one critic said, "A gripping story...stirring, psychologically profound, and not a page too long." About half way through, I felt it was many pages too long. The unfolding relationship between Julienne and Amand seems to be told in real time and includes the daily repetitions known to all households. And yet, by the end, I think I see the purpose of that long, drawn out, dailyness. We see the relationship grow and encounter set backs and hurdles. We see how one day does, in fact, differ from the day before. We live their lives alongside them and become part of the story, day after day. We know Julie and Amand. So when he suddenly becomes Louis who is married to Kathe, we have opinions! The length is the point. 

This is a great book. I highly recommend it. Get over the length. The payoff is worth it!


 

Saturday, May 16, 2026

The Quartet by Joseph J. Ellis

I'd had The Quartet by Joseph J. Ellis on my list for awhile. I don't even remember where the recommendation came from. But I am so glad I read this book. 

Obviously, I know a thing or two about American history, but this book brought some events at the time of the Founding into sharp relief and connected dots I had not. 

It's contention is that Washington, Madison, Hamilton, and John Jay together, through their sheer force of will, reimagined what the American Revolution was about and shaped the American Constitution to reflect their will. It's pretty compelling.

What was clear to all was that America stood on a precipice. What would it be now that it had won its independence from Britain. That single goal united all thirteen colonies, but they were united by little else. 

In fact, all the struggles Washington faced to fund the army through a recalcitrant Congress presaged the even harder battle after the war was won. Each state truly saw themselves as independent states. They united to defeat the British, but how to pay for that or how to run a united country afterwards was not a consideration. They had no desire to be the United States. Once the war was over, they did not even see the need for a functioning Congress. Of the delegates elected after the war, less than half even bothered to show up. The fact that we did not have an Executive or Judicial branch made perfect sense. Why would these thirteen, independent states need either. After all, hadn't they just thrown off an executive and judicial system which had tyrannized them? The Articles of Confederation, which controlled the colonies during the war, were intentionally weak, and apparently probably temporary. 

Washington recognized right away the trouble the nation was in. He despaired that he had fought for an independent United States just to see it quickly devolve into myriad self-interested, squabbling petty kingdoms. As long as each state retained its sovereignty, they did not think about common commerce, paying debts, military protection, or foreign policy. Any attempt to promulgate a stronger central government was derided as a return to the monarchy they had just thrown off. Yet Washington clearly saw the anarchy this opened America up to. Small states would be helpless in the face of an unpaid and angry military. States would eventually war with each other over boundaries, navigation rights, etc. And all would be sitting ducks to European powers just waiting for the dust to clear. 

John Jay went to England to negotiate the peace treaty after the war. So ineffective was the Continental Congress he left behind that he had no clear instructions or even a way to actually ratify the treaty he finally negotiated. Even when he came back with a phenomenal acquiesces from the British giving Americans all the land east of the Mississippi, the states' suspicions of each other prevented us from taking advantage of it. Unbelievably the North and South already looked at each other as competitors. Since the treaty would open up so much heretofore unclaimed land, both believed the other would use it to their disadvantage. Washington, a surveyor, knew the unbelievable gift the land was and was horrified that no one else seemed to see it. Jay saw what Washington saw and knew that a collection of infighting states would lead to one of the biggest missed opportunities in history.

Because Hamilton was not raised in a colony, he had no prejudicial connection to any one territory. In fact, he clearly saw the need for a united nation and the promise of political and economic advancement on the table. He also believed the war was about independence, not the overthrow of a particular type of governing system. He might have been ok returning to a monarchy as long as it was an American monarchy. He believed in America. He believed in the United States. He had no patience for The Thirteen Headstrong Squabbling States. 

But even with these heavy hitters, America owes all to Madison. It was he who saw most clearly the need for a central government to unite the colonies. Despite the fact that he felt a strong connection to his native country, Virginia, he worked tirelessly behind the scenes to push and prod the biggest players to come together to write a new governing document that would unite the disparate states into one country. A true politician, he waited until the moment was right, after Shay's Rebellion scared men like Washington into action. Although Hamilton jumped the gun in his excitement, calling a convention to "revise" the Articles, Madison politicked behind the scenes making sure delegates amenable to radical change would be the ones to show up. 

Then he developed a plan: The Virginia Plan. It gave each state power based on population, which coincidentally Virginia excelled in, and it gave the central government control over states' laws, meaning Virginia control over states laws. He lost in both arenas, rightfully so. But, he sparked a conversation about how to maintain the states' role in a federal government. Myriad compromises meant the line between state and national power would be blurred again and again. It would be up to future generation to find that line, but the seed was planted. Together these four laid out the principles that the Revolutionary War should have been fought for, but honestly wasn't. 

The book does a fantastic job of showing how close we came to winning our independence only to lose it again due to our own stubbornness, pride, and stupidity. Without these four men, we do not get the United States of America. These men saw with an exceptional kind of clarity the opportunity being handed to the states, a kind of clarity other mere mortals did not have. Through sheer force of will they created the nation we have today.

Saturday, February 28, 2026

Taking Manhattan by Russell Shorto

The book Taking Manhattan by Russell Shorto
was recommended to me somewhere, and since I am an American History nut, I had to read it. Shorto does an excellent job blending rich historical research and primary sources into an imminently readable story. We all know how it ends, but the journey is full of tension. 

Russell Shorto argues that the 1664 transition of New Amsterdam from Dutch to English control was a negotiated merger of cultures that established New York's multiethnic identity. The narrative highlights how the city's, and by extension America's, pluralistic DNA was formed through this pragmatic shift rather than simple military conquest. (AI)

He expertly crafts the narrative by highlighting the two key players: Richard Nicolls (for the English), and Peter Stuyvesant (for the Dutch). Both were ambitious and fiercely loyal to their respective authorities. Neither wanted to see the city destroyed. Together, they saved the city by reaching a compromise that would allow the island to continue to grow and flourish under the protection of the English using Dutch ways of doing business.

The best takeaway was at the end. He follows the Duke of York, for whom the city is named, into his role as King James II. When he appeared to threaten to push Catholicism on England, William of Orange, husband of James' sister Mary, seemed poised to invade. Much like the takeover of New Amsterdam, the English saw wisdom in compromising and allowing William and Mary to reign as sovereigns, pushing aside James II, in a bloodless, "Glorious" revolution. 

In the biggest irony of all, the English took Manhattan from the Dutch; the Dutch took England from the English.

Great book.


Monday, January 5, 2026

1356: A Novel by Bernard Cornwell

I love historical fiction, and Bernard Cornwell is one of my favorites. This is one of his rare stand-alone novels. Since I was not looking to read a whole series, I picked up 1356: A Novel from the library, having no idea what it referenced. I simply trusted Cornwell to make it interesting.

He did.

In the epilogue, he states his reason for this book is because he feels that the Battle of Poitiers has been largely forgotten compared to the Battle of Crécy or the Battle of Agincourt, which bookended the Hundred Years War between France and England. He's right. I hadn't heard of it, and it deserves more attention. 

Because the battle and time period is unfamiliar, I had a hard time in the beginning. He introduces a lot of characters from all over Britain and France. That can be confusing. People from Gascony (France) could very well be fighting on the side of the Brits, while people from Scotland (Britain) are fighting on the side of the French. Not to mention the traitors. 

We begin with Thomas, le Batard. He is the bastard son of an English nobleman. But he has disavowed that heritage and roams France as the leader of a mercenary army-for-hire. At the same time, a "black friar" has set about to retrieve a long-lost relic, le malice, the sword used by Saint Peter to defend Christ in the garden on the night of his betrayal. It is said that the sword contains the power of God but can only be used for good by the legitimate ruler. After finishing his latest gig, defeating Count Villon and "rescuing" the wife of the Count of Labrouillade, Thomas is tasked with finding le malice. 

At the same time, the king of France, Jean, is under enormous pressure to take on the English, led by the Prince of Whales, Edward, who are ravaging the French countryside. 

Twists and turns and adventures ensue as Thomas seeks to find le malice, evade capture by Labrouillade for taking the rescued wife to protect her from Labrouillade's abuse, and avoid the evil clergy also searching for le malice. Along the way he adds some colorful characters to his horde of merry men. 

Eventually they catch up to le malice, but it slips through their grasp and into the hands of the French. Unfortunately Thomas and his men are ordered to report to the camp of Prince Edward to fight in the long-rumored battle with the French forces. Le malice will have to wait.

The battle is remarkably lop-sided. According to what little records we have, the French lose over 2,500 men to the English' 40. Cornwell does a great job taking the scraps of history and weaving them into a believable story of how that could have happened. 

The "good guys" win, love triumphs, and le malice threatens no more. Win, win, win. 

Fun book. Fast-paced and great storytelling. 

Friday, July 25, 2025

The Face of Battle by John Keegan

Somewhere I saw this book highly recommended as one of the best books on war ever written. So I decided to give The Face of Battle by John Keegan a try. 

I'm not a huge fan of war books, but this one was interesting. 

He decides he will tell military history differently than it has been done in the past. He wants to look deeply into the face of the men who faced the battle. He states early on that he intends "to discuss wounds and their treatment, the mechanics of being taken prisoner, the nature of leadership at the most junior level, the role of compulsion in getting men to stand their ground, the incidence of accidents as a cause of death in war and, above all, the dimensions of the danger which different varieties of weapons offer to the soldier on the battlefield." (p. 77) He uses three battles as jumping off points for these discussion: Agincourt, Waterloo, and the Somme. He presents them in chronological order and also in order of magnitude. By starting with the much smaller, earlier battle of Agincourt, he provides a helpful place to compare later battles.

One plus, I got to read about battles I have only cursory knowledge of. And, he made it interesting.

He begins with the medieval battle of Agincourt on October 1415. It a small (by modern standards) battle that lasts only one day. It involves the French and the English and occurs at the end of the Hundred Years War. The killing and violence are horrifying, but Keegan makes note of the three most motivating factors: alcohol, King and religion, goods and glory. Although he thinks the last is probably the most important. At a time when even the battle-hardened looked to their priest for permission to kill, knowing that God and the King fought by your side was highly motivating. It didn't hurt (apparently) to be drunk, either. But knowing you would be rewarded in this life pushed men into a level of violence our modern sensibilities simply cannot comprehend. 

Then he moves to another French and English battle, Waterloo, on June 18, 1815. It's scope is much larger than the battle of Agincourt, covering over 2 square miles.  Despite the Duke of Wellington's desire to dismiss any literary or historical accounts of it, the battle looms large in the imagination. And it's no wonder. 

"For the first time in the history of the British army, each veteran of the battle was awarded a commemorative medal. He was to be known as a Waterloo Man and his single day of service on 18 June1815, was to count two years pension. This alone was sufficient to convince even the most unimaginative private soldier that he had survived an extraordinary event; officers were in no doubt of it from the moment the battle closed..." (p. 117). 

When Napoleon returned to France after his exile and the restoration of King Louis XVIII, the powers of Europe decided he would not return to power. They mustered four large armies to meet him, made up of the Austrians, Russians, Prussians, Belgiums, and an Anglo-Dutch army formed on a core English army. Napoleon, seeing the writing on the wall, decided to attack on of the first arrive, the Belgiums. After quickly dispensing them, he turned to the Anglo-Dutch army and attacked head on. That's exactly what the Duke of Wellington assumed he'd do. Although he initially tried a feint to the left, the battle commenced in the middle. The battle is generally considered to have five phases, although that was not obvious to the participants. Obviously in a battle this size the descriptions of the fighting and the wounded stagger the imagination. But once again, the French are dispatched and history moves on.

Moving forward into the future, Keegan describes the battle of the Somme. This is the horrifying trench warfare of World War I. Suffice it to say that this battle encompassed a much larger geographic location and lasted much longer than the others. 

From AI:

Core Themes of Keegan’s Analysis
  • The Brutality of Industrial Warfare: Keegan emphasizes how modern machinery—specifically automated machine guns and high-explosive artillery—turned the battlefield into a mechanized slaughterhouse that completely overwhelmed human endurance. [1, 2]
  • The Failure of the Bombardment: He details how the preliminary British artillery barrage failed to cut the thick German barbed wire or destroy deep underground concrete dugouts, leaving the defending German troops intact and ready. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]
  • The Human and Institutional Cost: Focusing on July 1, 1916, Keegan notes the devastating loss of 60,000 British casualties in a single day. He highlights the tragic optimism and courage of the volunteer "Pals" battalions who advanced into certain doom. [1, 2, 3, 4]
  • The Role of the Officer Corps: Keegan explores how the British public-school ethos shaped junior officers, maintaining a fragile sense of duty and social cohesion even as entire platoons were wiped out. [1]

For a book about warfare, I liked it far more than I thought I would. Unfortunately I waited too long to summarize it and didn't want to actually re-read it to get this summary. Ergo the AI addition at the end.

Tuesday, May 20, 2025

The Dovekeepers by Alice Hoffman

Our bookclub read The Dovekeepers by Alice Hoffman, the tale of four women who interacted during the time of Jewish resistance to the Romans on Masada. Loosely based on a true story, it describes the strengths and weaknesses of each of the women.

It begins with the journey of "The Assassin's Daughter," Yael, who is forced to flee Jerusalem with her father and another family, into the desert. When she finally arrives at the desert refuge of Masada, she is pregnant and hardened to the reality of the harsh life of a refugee. 

There she meets Shirah, an Egyptian and her daughter, Aziza, as well as Revka, a baker's widow. All of the women have their own story of love and loss and betrayal. All have made it to Masada with a deep desire to survive and all are strong in their own ways. Shirah is a mystic, full of magic and spells, despite their forbidden nature; Aziza harbors her own secret identity, disguising herself as a her brother and receiving acclaim for her heroics; Revka has proven she will kill, if the situation calls for it, to protect her family. 

Hoffman tells the story in sections, with each portion told in the voice of one of the four women. This necessitates a non-linear style as the story shifts back and forth in time. It's told in a lovely and haunting manner, full of beautiful imagery and language. The story is one I'm only vaguely familiar with and to have it dramatized was a delight.

Yet, I can't say I loved the book. 

All of the women are mystics of one sort or another, despite professing a Jewish faith. While they claim to serve the one true God, Adonai, a little reliance on the magic of spells and talisman seems to be the better option, especially when faced with particularly treacherous circumstances. In fact, the God they claim to serve never actually comes through for them. It is only magic that serves their purposes. And even that is not always to be relied upon. 

I guess, I wanted to see their faith in God manifest, but it never is. They live their lives reliant on themselves and whatever incantations and spells available. I actually didn't like any of the characters and could not see them as real people. They were too... much. All of them were very intense. Their thoughts, actions, and interactions were unlike those of anyone I've ever met. That made them seem wholly unreal and contrived. They are the version of women that this author wants women to be. But I didn't recognize them at all.

I can see why the book has great reviews. It's beautifully written and apparently deeply researched, but it wasn't for me.

Saturday, March 8, 2025

The Bletchley Riddle Hardcover by Ruta Sepetys and Steve Sheinkin

Our book club chose The Bletchley Riddle Hardcover by Ruta Sepetys and Steve Sheinkin. Apparently Ruta Sepetys writes historical fiction for adults and joined with Steve Sheinkin to write a YA novel.

I know a bit about Bletchley Park and the Enigma machine and Britains battle to break the German's code during World War II. That was the most interesting part. It was also the part that wasn't really the focus. 

Most of the novel deals with Lizzie desperate to find out the truth about her mother, Willa, who disappeared in Poland at the time of the German invasion. She and her brother, Jacob, work to uncover the clues left behind while holding down jobs at Bletchley Park.

For a book directed at tweenagers, it was very cute and readable. I wouldn't necessarily recommend it to an adult. There are much better books on the topic for that. 

But it was an enjoyable, quick read.

Friday, November 8, 2024

Man's Search for Meaning by Viktor Frankl

It was my time to choose a book for Book Club and I picked a book that had long been on my list: Man's Search for Meaning by Viktor Frankl. Dennis Prager says it's his favorite book and it changed his life.

So my expectations were high.

Plus I've read A Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich, The Gulag Archipelago, and Darkness at Noon. All in the same genre. 

I think because of my prior exposure to those books, this one did not seem as impactful. If anything, I'd say The Gulag Archipelago was the one that most made an impression on me.

Frankl writes as do the others, disjointed and out of chronological order. It's more thematic. It makes me wonder if having that kind of state-sponsored trauma impacts one's ability to tell the story. Or perhaps for them, it's not about the day-to-day events, but the larger meaning behind it all. 

Certainly Frankl wants to get at why he and his fellow prisoners suffered the way they did at the hands of the Nazis. Even before being detained, Frankl was spreading interested in the question of meaning and purpose in life. He was convinced that if a man did not have a sense of meaning or purpose he would die either mentally or even physically. So he looked on his fellow prisoners as a kind of science experiment. He clearly saw that those who gave up hope always died. It was those, like himself, who felt that their unjust suffering had a purpose of some sort that survived. 

I suppose the most remarkable thing about the book (and the others of the same genre) is how disconnected they were from their own tortures. They can discuss it dispassionately and disconnect from the personal experience of it. I suppose that necessary for survival. In Solzhenitsyn's case, he writes in a sarcastic manner, further removing himself from the horror. 

Frankl is also remarkable for the fact that he could forgive and move on once released from the prison. He recognized the humanity of each person, whether guard or prisoner. All had the ability to be cruel or kind. He famously states, "The line separating good and evil passes not through states, nor between classes, nor between political parties either — but right through every human heart — and through all human hearts."

The second half of his book discusses his theory of "Logotherapy." In a nutshell, after the war, he started his psychiatric practice helping people discover meaning in their lives. He was convinced that lack of meaning and purpose was the root of all mental suffering. He worked to reframe and redirect his patients towards discovering meaning in their circumstances, whatever they be.

One disappointment is that he never directs the reader to faith. I think he had faith in God as a result of his Judaism, but he never recommends that faith as a source of meaning and purpose. I suppose that's because he wants everyone, believer or not, to be able to access a life filled with meaning. That's a fair point. Obviously for me, a life whose meaning is found outside of God is just a temporary fill, but for Frankl that's enough. 

The book is worth reading because it's such a cultural touchstone. I'm sorry to say it did not impact me the way it impacted some. I wish it had. 

Thursday, September 26, 2024

Lincoln and Douglas by Allen C. Guelzo

One of my former students, Will Rhodes, who attends Princeton, gave me this book, signed by his professor and my favorite Lincoln scholar, Lincoln and Douglas by Allen C. Guelzo. What a delight this book was. 

Of course I'm familiar with the Lincoln/Douglas debates. I have read most if not all of them. But this book, following the pair from stop to stop really brought it alive for me. 

It begins with Lincoln's frustration at what Douglas was claiming on the campaign trail for senator of Illinois. Lincoln began to follow him and rebut his claims soon after Douglas' speeches. Annoyed, and definitely not in his best interest, Douglas agrees to formally debate Lincoln at each of the seven remaining campaign stops. 

Douglas is a very popular politician and his doctrine of "popular sovereignty" is popular as well. The idea that slavery should be voted up or down in a new territory and state appeals to Americans' democratic disposition. But Lincoln sees the end of this argument: slavery will exist, eventually, in every state in the union. 

Because the 17th Amendment has not yet been passed, senators are chosen by the state legislators. How this plays out practically is that men, like Douglas, campaign, not for themselves, but for legislative candidates pledged to support his bid for senator. It is, de facto, a popular vote on the senator, using the institutional constraints of the Constitution. While it is technically incorrect to say they are "running" for the Senate, it is arguable that that is exactly what they are doing. Lincoln, however, is a very dark horse in this race. He was a one-term member of the House of Representatives and a local lawyer. He is unknown outside of his home district and is not a national figure, by any means. 

These debates will change all that. 

With the advent of the new, anti-slavery Republican Party, the political ground was shifting rapidly. Whigs were in disarray and their vote is up for grabs. Henry Clay, the quintessential Whig is Lincoln's political hero, and his only hope is to persuade them that he, and the Republicans, are not rabid abolitionists, but align with the Founders. His opponent must simply seem reasonable. One thing I loved about his book is to discover how the political landscape is not so different from today. We think we are polarized now and mythologize some distant past where politics was civil and gentlemanly. That is a past that never existed and never will. Politics is bloodsport and Lincoln understood that better than most. 

In June of 1858, Lincoln was nominated to represents the Republicans in the Illinois Senate race and delivered his "House Divided" speech. Recalling Jesus' admonition that "a house divided against itself cannot stand," Lincoln posited that an America, similarly divided on the question of slavery, could not stand. To his detractors, this sounded like a call for civil war. To his admirers, he was finally asking that the question be answered, not in political or economic terms, but moral terms. Americans must answer whether slavery was right, and should therefore be national, or wrong, and should therefore be put on a path towards extinction. Lincoln believed he stood with the Founders and answer that slavery was immoral. But the intervening years had given way to political solutions and Americans, Lincoln believed, had forgotten the question. 

Guelzo does a great job uncovering the political consideration, and they were myriad, that Lincoln faced seeking to upset Douglas. He refers to letters and newspaper articles describing the in-the-weeds political needle Lincoln had to thread. That part is interesting and new to me, but what really fascinated me was the flow of the debates as they moved from town to town. While much was repeated, a new emphasis and nuance was introduced at each stop, culminating in the final, and what I believe to be the crux of the argument, debate. 

The first debate took place in Ottawa. While it was friendly territory for Lincoln, Douglas began by describing the Republican Party as a party of rabid abolitionists and challenged Lincoln to defend each of the planks of their Illinois State Convention platform. Of course each was framed to inflame the passions of the audience. Douglas referred back to the "House Divided" speech, implying Lincoln wanted war to settle the issue. In fact, Douglas stated that it was he, not Lincoln, on the side of the Founders. Weren't they the ones who "made this Government divided into free State and slave States, and left each State perfectly free to do as it please don the subject of slavery"? And as for the Declaration's claim that "All men are created equal"? Obviously that meant all white men are created equal. To read it any other way was to say the blacks and whites were equal in every way. This horrified the crowd. What Douglas left out was any mention of the already failed popular sovereignty doctrine in "bleeding" Kansas and the results of the Dred Scott Supreme Court case, which guaranteed slavery free passage anywhere in the nation. 

Unfortunately, Lincoln took the bait and proceeded to spend his time defending himself against Douglas' charges rather than make the moral case against slavery. He said he never signed on to the Illinois Republican platform. He did not believe blacks were equal in every sense, just as fellow humans. He did not want to abolish slavery everywhere, but simply keep it where it was. He tried to argue that Dred Scott had effectively made popular sovereignty moot. In fact, Lincoln argued, the decision was all part of a vast conspiracy to extend slavery nationally and, like any good conspiracy theorist, he tried to show that all evidence for or against the conspiracy only pointed to its validity. The crowd wouldn't hear it. They simply heard he was anti-war in the "good" war (Mexican American) and pro-war in the bad one (civil war) and wanted to give black people all the privileges currently given only to whites. 

In this debate, it's hard to call a "winner." Douglas went on a rabid attack and Lincoln spent his time on the ropes defending himself. Yet he did defend himself. Against the nation's best debater, that seemed like a win. 

The second debate took place at Freeport. Once again the crowds showed up for what promised to be a robust political spectacle. This time Lincoln spoke first. Lincoln began on the defensive, stating all of the queries Douglas had posed at the last debate and answering them all again. In fact, he answered them in such a way that even his admirers felt he had given away the entire Republican doctrine. But as a lawyer, Lincoln understood that it's better to give up what you cannot keep and save one irrefutable argument in your pocket. This was his belief that only Congress had the right to answer the slavery question in the territories. This went directly against popular sovereignty and Dred Scott. Then Lincoln went on the offensive asking Douglas to defend his positions in light of Dred Scott which ruled that any new territories could not lawfully keep out slavery. Lincoln, through a series of questions, walked Douglas through to the only logical conclusion: that Douglas would be ok with all new territories entering the Union as slave territories and that there was nothing to be done about it. This seems to have very much concerned the people of the free state of Illinois. He also made clear that what Douglas claimed to be the platform of the Illinois state Republicans was actually that of another organization and that Douglas had no right to hold him accountable to it. He claimed Douglas was careless in his facts and therefore could not be trusted.

Douglas responded by breezing past Lincoln's question, reiterating his popular sovereignty mantra, once again, as if Dred Scott had not made it moot. He then went on to disparage Lincoln as a "Black Republican," and implied that Lincoln stood for mixing of the races on every level. Again and again, Douglas plays the race card and appeals to the bigotry of his audience. 

The most important part of this second debate was Lincoln's second question to Douglas at Freeport, "Can the people of the United States Territory, in any lawful way, against the wishes of any citizen of the United States, exclude slavery from its limits prior to the formation of a State Constitution?" The key word is "lawful." Lincoln knew the Dred Scott decision had already answered this question with a "no," since slaves were property and could not be excluded based on the territories' borders. But Douglas could not afford to acknowledge this. He wanted to straddle the fence with his "don't care" philosophy towards the legality of slavery in any particular state. This question would pursue him time and again at subsequent debates. This is Lincoln playing the long game. He knew in 1858 that Douglas' answer might satisfy the people of Illinois, but he knew Douglas had presidential ambitions and that question would destroy any chance he had on the national stage in 1860. Guelzo believes Lincoln was also desperate to deny Douglas a place at the top of the Republican ticket. He could see Douglas believing he could unite northern Democrats with Republicans and win in a landslide. Lincoln saw that as the death of the Republican Party. 

The third debate took place in the southern town of Jonesboro. In this very poor and largely illiterate town, Douglas had a hard time connecting and certainly had no energy to feed off of. Although the area definitely leaned pro-slavery, Douglas spent a good deal of time on Republican inter-party weeds before finally getting to his main point about Lincoln's supposed desire to give black people all the civil rights enjoyed by whites. He reiterated that it was he, not Lincoln, upholding the Founders' intentions to let each state decide the slavery question for itself. 

Lincoln agreed that the Founders had indeed left slavery up to the states, but disagreed that they intended that situation to prevail. He pointed out evidence that the Founders had always hoped to see slavery on a path to extinction. He also tried, with little success, to tie Douglas to some Democratic positions that sounded on slavery exactly like Lincoln's. Lincoln denied that he was agitating for war, but did remind the people the closest they got to war was the perpetual question of slavery with the addition of each new territory. Lincoln did, however, add a question concerning a federal "slave code" that would ensure the property rights in slavery in any territory. This, like the second Freeport question, was a damned if you do, damned if you don't question. Douglas could not concede any federal right to regulate slavery in the territories, because they could make it legal everywhere. He also could not say the federal government could protect a state in its anti-slavery legislation either. Douglas simply reverted to his magical panacea of "popular sovereignty." 

No clear winner emerged from this southern excursion, but Lincoln had little to lose in unfriendly territory anyways.

The fourth debate took place in Charleston, a Whig stronghold. While hating slavery, they also abhorred the idea of equality in civil rights. Lincoln was therefore forced to clarify that he did not believe blacks were equal in any way other than natural human rights. This marks a low point and is the basis for declaring Lincoln a racist. He certainly panders to a racist crowd, trying to thread the needle between full acknowledgment of the humanity of blacks and full social equality. 

Douglas responded with his own conspiracy of the ways in which Lincoln and the Republicans were seeking to make the Whigs abolitionists. He knew this to be an anathema. He also rejected Lincolns forceful claims to only want human rights for blacks by saying Lincoln opposed Dred Scott, which made citizenship illegal for blacks. He therefore implied that Lincoln must be for citizenship for blacks and all that entails. 

While Lincoln wanted to argue that he opposed Dred Scott because it put the slavery question in the hands of the Supreme Court, arguing for the states to decide on the civil rights of black people edged a little too close to Douglas' popular sovereignty doctrine. He also had to spend time diffusing Douglas conspiracy charges of "abolitioning" the Whig party. But Lincoln scored a few points. He made Douglas look inconsistent on his "don't care" policy regarding slavery by showing Douglas had actually voted against legal provisions that would have helped the anti-slavery movement. He used the morality of slavery as a cudgel against Douglas and reiterated that the best and least harmful path forward was the one the Founders advocated, an inexorable path to extinction. And, most importantly, he stood his ground. The people came to see Lincoln as the equal of the "Little Giant" Douglas when it came to the debates. 

The fifth debate took place in Galesburg, friendly territory for Lincoln. Plus Douglas had been wearing himself out physically, battling bronchitis, and was becoming more and more dependent on the bottle. He trotted out his tired arguments on popular sovereignty and tried to hold himself out as a man willing to stand up to both pro- and anti-slavery forces and fight for the will of the people. But he lacked energy and enthusiasm.

Lincoln, in contrast, came out swinging. Lincoln dismissed most of the speech for what it was, simply the same things Douglas had said at every stop. He would focus, however, on the Declaration's claim that "all men are created equal." Lincoln pointed out that one could search in vain for any evidence at all that the Founders only intended it to apply to white people. He pointed out that the author, Jefferson himself, "trembled" when he considered that God is just and that slavery would never gain His favor. Here Lincoln became quite elevated indicating that if slavery is right or wrong based on a majority's opinion, then morality itself is on the ballot. If Douglas continued to willfully blind himself to Lincoln's natural law argument that black and white people are inherently equal as humans, then Douglas would bring down the entire moral edifice of right and wrong. If Douglas persisted in claiming he "don't care" whether slavery is voted up or down, and refused to recognize the moral degeneracy of slavery, then Douglas had no right to speak of "right" and "wrong" in any context. Right and wrong then became entirely dependent on the mood of the electorate. Lincoln ended by saying that the only way to put the immoral practice of slavery on a path to extinction was to elect Republicans. 

In his rebuttal, Douglas found his fire. He rabidly called out Lincoln for hypocrisy, literally foaming at the mouth and shaking his fist. He said Lincoln was not for equality in unfriendly territory like Jonesboro but now claimed he was for equality in friendly Galesburg. He angrily defended his honor against Lincoln's charges of lying about the Republican resolution brought up in the first debate. He claimed that Lincoln, with his opposition to Dred Scott, invited mob rule. 

The debate ended with a defeated and deflated Douglas, and a Lincoln who could now see a path forward on offense. 

The sixth debate took place at Quincy, on the border of slave state Missouri. Lincoln spoke first, coming after Douglas with a vengeance. He called Douglas a liar for continuing to pin resolution on him that Lincoln had not agreed to; he called Douglas a dodger for refusing to see the logic of Dred Scott and the way it demolished his popular sovereignty doctrine; and he called out Douglas for willfully refusing to debate on the moral principle of slavery and obfuscating instead with racial rhetoric. Lincoln made it exceptionally clear that the reason slavery presented a fight every time it came up was because Americans knew it was a moral question: some believed it to be wrong, the Republicans; some believed to be right, the Democrats. Lincoln posited that that was the only question up for consideration. Was slavery right or wrong? Was it a refutation of the Founders and the Natural Law upon which the nation had been founded or was it simply another political position to be left to political institutions? The audience could join with the Republicans and at least acknowledge it as a moral wrong, and leave the "then what" to the future or join with the Democrats and deny even the immorality of the institution. 

Douglas, addled in in poor form, continued to deny slavery was a moral issue. He agreed with Lincoln that truly didn't care about the morality of slavery. For him all the agitation that came with the slavery question was promulgated by abolitionist like Lincoln. He continued to claim he was directionally correct in tying Lincoln to the resolutions put forth in the first debate, if not factually correct. He defended his honor against Lincoln's charges of lying and being part of a conspiracy to extend slavery to the whole nation. He seemed genuinely unable to understand Lincoln's point about Dred Scott's protection of slavery in any territory, and by extension, any state. He simply could not see why a territory or state could not disallow slavery as they would any other property, like alcohol. 

Lincoln responded that the only question under consideration was, once again, the morality of slavery. ALL opposition to the institution stemmed from moral opposition. The Founders opposed it on moral grounds and put it on a path to extinction. Had not the cotton gin made it economically feasible, it would have remained on that path. It was Douglas, not Lincoln, who departed from the American ideal. To the charge of changing his message to suit his audience, Lincoln offered his notes from each debate and speech he'd given to show that his message remained the same. 

The seventh and final debate took place in Alton. Douglas began, looking quite haggard from the exertions and the alcohol. Douglas harkened back to the "House Divided" speech and once again portrayed Lincoln as a war-monger. He continued to paint Lincoln as a man who believed in civil and social equality between the races. He accused Lincoln of slandering the Founders in refusing to accept a permanently half-slave and half-free nation. He pointed out that he had broken with the Democrats over slavery numerous times, but that Lincoln had refused to reject the position of the extreme abolitionists. Lincoln simply listened to the charges he had heard again and again. Lincoln wanted civil war. Lincoln was a n_____ lover. Douglas was the true hero who stood up for the rights of the people.

Lincoln stood and made a joke that watching Douglas distance himself from the pro-slavery aspects of his party was like a battered wife watching her husband fight off a bear: she wasn't sure who to root for. 

Then he got down to business. Douglas had claimed that Lincoln refused to acknowledge the authority of the Supreme Court by rejecting the logic of Dred Scott. Lincoln said that was nothing compared to Douglas' willful misrepresentation of the Declaration of Independence. Lincoln quoted from the Great Compromiser (and notable Whig) Henry Clay to the effect that all men are created equal, but that does not always imply social and civil equality (i.e. women and children were not civilly and socially equal to men). In opposing the "House Divided" speech, Lincoln put Douglas on the side of satan disparaging the Bible, as it was biblically inspired. Lincoln reiterated the clear evidence that the Founders believed they had put slavery on a path to extinction. Pulling the rug out from Douglas' popular sovereignty argument, Lincoln stated that he no problem with the principle if contained to subjects over which the majority had the right to decide. He simply believed morality fell outside that boundary. And he claimed everyone listening knew that. Finally Lincoln boiled his entire argument down to one statement, "The real issue in this controversy--the one pressing upon every mind--is the sentiment on the part of one class that looks upon the institution of slavery as a wrong, and of another class that does not look upon it as a wrong." (p. 265) All practical questions of how to deal with the institution as it existed must be pushed aside until that fundamental question could be answered. 

In fact, argued Lincoln, the arguments for slavery were identical to the arguments for a king, rejected by our Founders. Slavery did not just dehumanize black people, it introduced the idea of a hierarchy among people. Worse, according to Douglas, this hierarchy could be determined by a vote! "Those who deny freedom to others, deserve it not for themselves, and, under a just God, can not long retain it" (p. 267). Thus the apex of his argument was formed. After starting out on the defense, Lincoln had moved solidly into offense.

Douglas was wholly unable to rebut him. He sunk back to his tired arguments of blaming the abolitionists for all the unrest. He deeply resented Lincoln's resort to the question of morality for it implied that Douglas was, himself, immoral. He stood solidly with all those who before him had punted on the question of morality and appealed to the pragmatism of popular sovereignty. 

Douglas was a broken and defeated man.

Yet, Lincoln did not win the Senate campaign. By a narrow margin, pro-Douglas legislators were voted into office. It was always a long shot anyways. 

But, in 1860, Lincoln won the bigger prize: the presidency. The nation would go to war, which Lincoln vigorously opposed, to settle the slavery question once and for all. Lincoln would be magnanimous in victory as he appealed to the "better angels" of our nature. 

I'm so glad I got to dive into the details of each debate from so well-respected a scholar as Allen Guelzo. My appreciation for Lincoln rose tremendously.


*note bene: Guelzo makes a handwritten correction to a typo and signs it on page 238.